Calcite dissolution: Effects of trace cations naturally present in Iceland spar calcites

Abstract

In situ dissolution experiments on a set of pure, optical quality Iceland spar calcite samples from four different localities showed etch pit step retreat rates to be inversely proportional to total inherent trace cation composition. Atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS) revealed Fe2+, Mg2+, Mn2+ and Sr2+ in amounts varying from a few to hundreds of ppm. We used a very simple experimental set-up, with an Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) fluid cell and a droplet of MilliQ water. As the calcite dissolved and approached equilibrium with the solution, trace cations were released, which were then present for interaction with the dissolving surface. We monitored continuous free-drift dissolution, in situ, on fresh {1 0 over(1, ̄) 4} cleavage surfaces for up to 40 min. Dissolution produced one-layer-deep, rhombic etch pits that continually expanded as we collected images. The rhombohedral symmetry of calcite defines two obtuse and two acute edges on the cleavage surface of etch pits and these, as expected from previous work, had different dissolution rates. Despite identical experimental conditions for all samples, we observed lower step retreat rates for both obtuse and acute edges on calcite characterised by relatively high trace cation composition. Increased cation concentration, particularly Mn, was also correlated with rounding of obtuse-obtuse corners, resulting in obtuse step retreat rates similar to those for acute sides. Physcial limitations of the AFM technique were taken into account when measuring step rate retreat and results were collected only from single-layer etch pits, which represent crystalline calcite with minimal defects. Dissolution rates presented here are thus lower than previous reports for studies of deep etch pits and where the physical limitations of imaging may not have been considered. In addition to molecular-level proof that divalent cations inherent at ppm levels in the calcite affect the dissolution process, these results show that pure, optical quality Iceland spar calcite should not be considered pure in the chemical sense. The results imply that dissolution rates determined for ideal systems with pure, synthetic or natural, materials may be considered as the boundary condition for dissolution in real systems in nature, where cations are always present both in the solution and in the initial solid. © 2006 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.