Comparisons of raman lidar measurements of tropospheric water vapor profiles with radiosondes, hygrometers on the meteorological observation tower, and GPS at Tsukuba, Japan

Abstract

The vertical distribution profiles of the water vapor mixing ratio (w) were measured by Raman lidar at the Meteorological Research Institute, Japan, during the period from 2000 to 2004. The measured values were compared with those obtained with radiosondes, hygrometers on a meteorological observation tower, and global positioning system (GPS) antennas near the lidar site. The values of w obtained with the lidar were lower than those obtained with the corrected Meisei RS2-91 radiosonde by 1.2% on average and higher than those obtained with the corrected Vaisala RS80-A radiosonde by 17% for w ≥ 0.5 g kg-1. The lidar data were higher than those radiosondes' data by 19% or 33% for w < 0.5 g kg-1. The vertical variations of w obtained with the lidar differed from those obtained with the Meisei RS-01G radiosonde and Meteolabor Snow White radiosonde by 5% on average for w ≥ 0.5 g kg-1. The lidar data were lower than those radiosondes' data by 37% or 39% for w < 0.5 g kg-1. The temporal variations of w obtained with the lidar and the hygrometers on the meteorological tower agreed to within 0.4% at a height of 213 m, although the absolute values differed systematically by 9%-14% due to the incomplete overlap of the laser beam and the receiver's field of view at heights between 50 and 150 m. The precipitable water vapor obtained with the lidar indicated a mean positive bias of 2 mm (9%-11%) relative to those obtained with GPS. The lidar water vapor calibration coefficient that was calculated using RS2-91 radiosonde data varied by 11% during an 18-month period. Therefore, it is necessary to develop an accurate, yet convenient, method for determining the calibration coefficient for the use of the lidar. © 2007 American Meteorological Society.