Sign up & Download
Sign in

K42: building a complete operating system

by Orran Krieger, Mark Mergen, Amos Waterland, Volkmar Uhlig, Marc Auslander, Bryan Rosenburg, Robert W Wisniewski, Jimi Xenidis, Dilma Da Silva, Michal Ostrowski, Jonathan Appavoo, Maria Butrico show all authors
ACM SIGOPS Operating Systems Review (2006)

Cite this document (BETA)

Available from portal.acm.org
Page 1
hidden

K42: building a complete operating system

K42: Building a Complete Operating System
Orran Krieger Marc Auslander Bryan Rosenburg Robert W. Wisniewski
Jimi Xenidis Dilma Da Silva Michal Ostrowski Jonathan Appavoo
Maria Butrico Mark Mergen Amos Waterland Volkmar Uhlig
ABSTRACT
 

fiffffiflffiffi  ff "!fffl#%$&ff
'(ffifl !)  *!+,- &.
 /0
$1ff#! /243&4ffi+65ffi  /
74 ff8fl8ff9   8ffi:- ;<fl
= *>

: ?@
=A .B43&4ffi+C5ffi  /= EDF; %
=$1ffi G
=8&ffflffi0!
H5FI!

5&ffi  /= "5Jff
+K/ff
=8 H5J8$J
$1ff L
ff+KffiA A1!
5%
M1@ fl"!
AN.
!MA =OPflffi84
=+, Q"!MA =OE!
5;+2!
 #!
 H!MA =D:RI<$ff
S'4ffifl:T!
UM1.
/
8 V XWffiY=Y=Z<M32!9ffi!
+[!ST\4]I^`_Uffi ffi!fffl#aDcb:dffcA-!
4@  
3"!ffff!
:M1ffi ;!25ffid=ffiA
=$+, >@feP
ff U
= ;%gff
=+hM1.
iIffi j N*V
%(I >i3,ffffi "!Sffflfff!
H505ffid=ffiA
=$1ff!
flfff
= \4]T^7O
fl
=A A-!
M1
ff#!S /G8 -d=ff N-ffiO!
H5k H!S-
H!AUA-!
M1
ff#!
ff-ffiDl
 8$$1
ff Jnma >8*GoUp\%!
5qoU]\fO! H5G-r!
MA n
sff8 k8 &.
+,
>5&NtH"5,mE- >8&*,!
$$A  fl"!
T! H5,A -M&ff#!ff ffiffiDcRIU!
$$ff
=!
fl#2


uv fi0
s!flf ffid, fl"!Ag!M A N(3G! H5Fflffi84
=+, Q"!
M A-Ni3v!

M1ffi j 8flflffiffi 4L8AwD
RIJ$&ff
'(ffifl9H!x$ff
>5&8flffiffi5X$1
   d<ffffi "!Sffflfsffffi 8ANffiOaH!:ff.
 8AN"5n nflffi
 ff-M8
= I
,ma >8*V! H52xyUffi n3&$1ffd> 
ff@
=
p
"ff"O>!
5%flffi
- >8ffi 
xM1T!@ff-fl#r$Ag!S L
ff+zL
ff*&$A-
ff /x43&4.
+6
(I!ff<ffiflf 
A-
/
3DR{
>5!ffi3O1O1 :
= 9
|9u3n*>.
$A
ff#!
ff 32$A-! 
ff+,I ,}9bx~T T€>oxR.(bJ$&ff
=/
ff#!+jO> IM1.
 /r8 "5n!
!J$ff

i3$ /rd flffiA x j\4]I^7 Up~_‚T0$&ff
'(ffifl"O
! H5v 9M1ffi /n8 "5vM3s8  dff N ffi<!
5v H!S-
H!AA-!
M9
ff%*>.
$A
ff#!
ff 37ff "!fffl#ƒD2\( X 9$H!
$1fff"O{I,$&ff
Sd&-5&r   /=< >

M8 A-5 /2! ;ffi Nff434+hM3n5  flffi8  - /,+,
 d
!
= j!
H5
 4
ff 3r
E>O5ffi flff M- /9 |L8 H5!
+,ffi #!
A>ffifl# 
=A
=/
-ffiO&!
H5
$&ffffi ffi  /v!
k
d=ffd>-f„
U0ff "!fffl#ƒ5& fffl
= rn!Sd=
M1ffi j$8&ff 8 /&D
Categories and Subject Descriptors
}%D &D …F† ‡Jˆ|‰>ŁS‹Œ"LŽa‘E’a“ffiŒffi‰”v“•—–%˜:ffi ff#!
Aw™|}JD D Ws† ‡Jˆ|‰&ŁS‹Œ"LŽ{
P’{“ffiŒffi‰”v“•—–Fp|ff
flffi s^j!
!
/=+, >"™:}JD D Wq† ‡Jˆ|‰>ŁS‹Œ"LŽahE’a“š
Œ‰”7“•B–ap)ff
flffiffi |^j! H!/=+,ffi 4›œsž&Ÿ  w¡ ¢H£ ¤"¥#¦f§§¡L¨>©H™
}JD D 9† ‡Jˆ|‰>Ł‹Œ"LŽ{
P’{“ffiŒffi‰”v“•—–,>
ff#!/=0^j!
!
/
ffi+,ffi "™}%D &D ªF† ‡Jˆ|‰>ŁS‹Œ"LŽaKE’a“š
Œ‰”7“•B–c€  A <>3&4ffi+,@^j! H!/=ffi+,ffi "™}JD D ;† ‡Jˆ‰>ŁS‹ŒffiLŽ{«E’a“š
Œ‰”7“•B–7‚
+,+J8  fl"!
2^j! H!
/
ffi+,ffi "™}JD D ¬q† ‡Jˆ|‰&ŁS‹Œ"LŽ{
P’{“ffiŒffi‰”v“•—–zbUff#!
/
 Q"!
­! H5l}:ffi  /= a™0}JD D ®z† ‡Jˆ|‰&ŁS‹Œ"LŽ{
P’{“ffiŒffi‰”v“•—–p ff 
ff+2! flffi
General Terms
oA /=
ffN+,ffiO p fff L
ff+2! flffi
O }:ffi  /=

\4]T^¯R:D°D±F!
= 0_U "!fffl#s‚ffi ff
RI  I
ffuxI!
) 8$$1
ff ffi5< <$H!ff  M>3!}UoU_UpPokp~|_‚T9/ff#!

fl
=  ff#!
fl >8+%M1ffT²:]T‚³xª
…=ª=Y
…=…
…

Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for
persona l or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are
not made or di stributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies
bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, or
republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific
permission and/or a fee.
EuroSys’06, April 18-21, 2006, Leuven, Belgium.
Copyright 2006 ACM 1-59593-322-0/06/0004...´ 5.00.
Keywords

=$1fff#! /@43&4ffi+µ5ffi  /
aO  fl"!
A-!MA I
=$1fff#! /@43&4ffi+,ffiOSflffi84
=+, Q.
!
MA 
=$1ff#!S- /,43&4ffi+,
1. BACKGROUND
\( qW"Y=Y
Zs2M1ffi/! fin
;*&$A
ffV!j [
$1ff#! /;43&4ffi+
5 -/
G4 ff8fl8&ff2
ffJ fl"!
A-!
M A-Ni3Ocfl84
=+, Q"!M A N(3O!
5F+2!
 .
#!
 !
M A N(3V VUfl
= *>T
{A-!ff/=f.i fl
=$1
ff@
=A .B43&4ffi+?fff.
 "!Sffflffi   8ffiDj J5&ffi  /= FT!%M!
 "57
= Fflffi8&ff ffffi <
iT!Sff
!
5V!ff#5>T!ffUffiflf 
A-
/
30!
5V
0$&ff"5 fl
T
a@ffU
= 
ffifl# 
=A
=/
-UIfff<"!=5&"5ED\( n  fl
= jI<5&ffi flff M1
= 
$ffffi5 fl
= r!
5G5  flffi8 %,ffffi 8AN /sffifl# 
=A
=/3G5ffifl- 
ffiD
oIn7ffi 5¶
J7$!
$1ff"OUIvffd& ·
"·X$ffffi5 fl
= 
fl#H!
/="59
Sdff A NLI
$ff
S'4fl!
59ffffi 8AN- /:fl#H! /=
 nUffiflf  fl"!A{5& fffl
= 
{x$&ff
'(ffifl"D
1.1 Technology predictions
3V$ffffi5 fl
= @+2!=5&x vW"Y
Y=ZJIfff=–
W=Dœs¡—¥£ ¤§¤(¸f s¹0¡L¨Hº¤
»|§2»c¤
ž&Ÿ ºFº¤
¼%¡L¨1½
 i¦n ¾¦;¥ffiŸ ¡B¦f¨ 9§B¢&½=¥f¦f¿
½
¨1ºs»¤žŸ º;¡L¨H¥£¦ ½
§¡L¨>©=Ÿ Àvº¤
¼%¡L¨1½ i¦V§¦f£fÁ
¦f£V§À
§ i¦f¼J§Âv]3
V+,g5«WffiY=Y
…
ffiOI$&ff"5 fl
r+2!
52M3fiA "!=5&- /7fl
=  8AN .
- /%tff+, H5&-flffi!"52Ã:  *JI
=8A-5n5 !$$1"!SffTff
=+[!
A APM8
 /=&.i H57 fffdff<!
5X±¶ H5&
"@<
=8A-5F5&
=+, H!Sr+,
=4
+2!ffuffiD
>Dœsž&Ÿ  w¡ ¢H£ ¤"¥#¦f§§f¤
£#§7»c¤
ž&Ÿ ºkÄf¦ ¥¤
¼,¦7¡L¨1¥£ ¦½§#¡¨>©=Ÿ ÀG¡L¼:¢&¤£f B½
¨ 
½
 aÄ#¤ ¾< ¾¦¾>¡-©S¾%½
¨HºxŸ ¤
»v¦f¨1ºÂ)€
ffac /=ffi 5EOS$ff
S'4fl
- 7!
flffi!=5+,g!X† OW=O 
…S•c5ffi+,
4 ff#!ffi5;!A-!Sff/=r fl"!A 
²:Ã^joµ+J8A  $&ff
flffiffi 
ffU!ff"!
  MA <!
5nfl"! jM195ffid=ffiAN.

=$1"5«
GM1s$ff flffiSÅS$1ff L
ff+2!
flffi7fl
=+,$1N d;@NÆ5& 4.
 ff-M8"543&4ffi+,ffiD €
ff A
"Gffi H5POS- flff"! - /x >8+r.
M1ff:
| ff#!
  4
ff:Iff93& ffiA-5 /2 +2!
A A ff:-+,$&ff
Sdffi+,ffi 

r  /=A flffi
ffffiffiO1! H5V  ffi+,"5V!T:ffidff@ flfff"!
  /
5ffi   i3;
 ff#!
  4
ffxI
8A-5s- 4"!=5sM1<8 "5;L
ff+,
ff
flffi
ffffiU!
5V&ff"!=5&
j!Jfl# $ED
ª&DrÇa¾¦,¥#¤§# :¤4¸J¼r½
¡L¨ B½¡L¨¡L¨©j½
¨1ºs¦f¨>¾½
¨H¥¡L¨>©s¥ž>£f£ ¦f¨ ¤#¢¦f£È
½
 w¡L¨>©r§À
§ i¦f¼%§x»c¤
ž&Ÿ º%©
£4¤
»«¡¨1¥£¦ ½
§¡L¨©=Ÿ À¢H£ ¤"¾>¡—Ä¡L w¡LÁ
¦<¤
Á
¦f£
 w¡L¼2¦"·~)*&-4 /«
=$1fff#! /ƒ43&4ffi+,0Ifffi5&ffi  /= "5l!
+,
= 
A   flj43&4ffi+,ffiOI@Nƒ5!#!v4 ff8fl8ffffi2! H5k$1
=A  fl3
-+,$A ffi+,ffi #!
= P $ff"!
5!
flff
 {|43&4ffi+jD{&8flfx/
A
=MH!A
u& 
"@A-ffi5/=s+2!uffi,+2!
 ffi !
fls5NÉ,flffi8A VM1ffiflffi!
8 sNV 
H!ff#5J
9ffi  8ff@H!ScfePffiflI
 ! +2!A-Aflf!
/
U cflffi
= &.
#!
 "5PDƒRIj5& Érflffi8AN(3G
x  
Sd=!S- /7 k 8fl#q43&4ffi+,
T!
 -MN- /9b9ff "!fffl#,!
5J+2!
u> /UNcd=ff 3%5NÉ,flffi8A 

r!ePflflffi
=+,+,ffflg!A143&4ffi+,ffiDRIx$A-!
flffiffiT@ff*& 4 .
- /G
=$1ff#!S- /q43&4ffi+,n5-5ƒH!"dsIA-A95&tH "5ƒ
=M>'4fl .

ff ffi "50 ff L!
flffiffiffiO=D /D OHd> 
>5xA-!ffi3ff"O4 ff"!
+,ffiO5>ff-d=ffffiO
fl=D OH!A A-
""5j/
ff"!SffU-  
Sd
!
= ED
DJÊ)ž&§ B¤
¼%¡-Ë"½Ä¡wŸ ¡L wÀ:½
¨Hº¦ Ì
 i¦f¨§¡—Ä¡wŸ ¡ wÀ:»c¤
ž&Ÿ ºxÄ#¦ ¥#¤¼2¦¡L¨1¥£ ¦ ½
§#È
¡L¨>©=Ÿ Àx¥£f¡L w¡w¥#½
Ÿ& B¤<¤f¢¦f£ ½ w¡L¨>©§#À§ i¦f¼J§ÂcRIffcI!
!Ufl
=  -5>.
ff#!
MA-!
+,
8 
ffffi "!Sffflf< <UWffiY=Y=…)
= <flffi84
+, Q"!
MA-
Page 2
hidden
!
5q*>ffi   MA ;
=$1ff#!S /fi43&4ffi+,ffiDp)ff
'(ffifl0A- uj~|*>.

=u=ff ffiA—†NWffi•—O&$- a† ¬S•—OI! H5GÍ: 
† ª&W•U5&ffi+,
= 4 ff#!"5FH!S
$1ff 
ff+2!
flffi9/!- :flffi
8A-5jM19!
fl# ffid="5jN)%b0 Ufl84.

=+, Qffiffi5v
j2 ffiffi5<
 $1ffiflffiNtHfl0!
$$A  fl"!
ffiD7\( v
flffi
>f*&|
1A-!ff/
+%8AN $ff
flffi 
ff|@ %$1
ffi -!
A AN3%+2!
3
  +J8A #! ffi
8I'(
=MffiO flffi84
+,-Qffi!
M A N(3X ffiffi+,ffi57ffid 7+,
ff
flffN fl"!
AwD
Î Dj¹V¡L ¾>¡L¨%ÏÁ
¦À¦ ½
£#§%½=ŸLŸP¼,½¥#¾¡L¨P¦f§»c¤
ž&Ÿ ºnÄ#¦%ÐÑvÄ¡L iÂT^n\(p
!
5FoUA $H!n!=5v!ANff"!=5>3fi5+,
= 4 ff#!S"5X!9, flff.
+,ffi #!
A:flffi
=4;
J 8$$1
ff - /«Z
.BMNs!
55>ffffi   /k-n+,- &.
 +2!
A<
= ‘fl# $‘!Sff"!¶!
5l$1
"Iffv5    $H!S-
aDÒ]cffifl"!
8 
Z
.BMN7!=55>ffffi   /ƒ sM1ffi tHflffi-!A<
ffX
=+,F
iT!ff
OrN
 ffiffi+,ffi5qH!SVªS.BM 0$A-!S L
ff+,,
=8A-5ƒ

5 !
$$1"!ff"D
oU  
8 flffi+,ffi PM>3xflf-$9+2! &8&w!fl8ffffa 8$$1
ff "5x ffiD
b: 2$-flffi0

iT!Sff0H!SJflffi!
fiM1ffi t<ff
+Ó!sZ
.BMN
!fffl#Nffiflf8ffs V;
=$1ff#!S- /G434+jD‘oU  8+, /FZ
.
MN|!
55>ffffi   /!A-A
"@|
=$&-+, Q"!S
=  &ff
=8/=
8 
$.
ff#!S- /434+jO%
D /&D Or+2!
$$ /«!
A Ar$>3&  fl"!AJ+,ffi+,
ff 3O
!=55 /4#!!
59A
fl#uMNa
$1
= ffffiO=!"d
=-5 /fl
=+,$A N.
fl"!S"5J5!#!:4 ff8fl8ffffi)M398 - /:$1
ffi g!A A 3<A-!ff/
@d&Nff 8!
A
ff#!
/=ffi@ff#!ffTH! jH!  /&Offl=D
±v9 
"‘5&- fl8 Uffiflf 
A-
/
3s5&Nffffifl
= U <$&ff"5 fl

A "508T
J$8ff 8
D
1.2 Technology directions
^j! 32
=$1ff#!S- /J43&4ffi+Kffffi "!fffl#n  -!S-d=ffiTflf
= 
J*&$A
ff
-5"!Tff
=8/=V flffffi+, >#!A1flf!
/=ffiI
%*&-4 /J43&4ffi+,ffiD
±vcM1A- ffid="5:H!S{|fl#H! /={ ffiflf 
A-
/
3  flffi|*&-4 /

$1ff#! /q43&4ffi+,2Iff75 -/
"5ƒff7  /
NtHfl"! ;ffi 
8/
aO
! H5q!2;fl
=40
9+2!
 #!
 - /v
 s434+,2I!
V /=
 
=8/=EO)H!<
$1ff#! /;43&4ffi+¯ffffi ffi!fffl#Fff
=+C!jflffiA "! fi Ag!S
 
=8Ag50M1x8 5ff #!uffi aD
±vX5ffi  /= "5¶!F43&4ffi+ÔH!S0I!
V  +,-A-!Sffj ƒ+2!
3kT!ffi3&V

<~|*&
=u=ff ffiAwO@ff9+J8flfVL8 fl
= !
A N(3;  +,$A ffi+,ffi "5V-
A  Mff#!Sff ffic <T!$$A  fl"!S-
ffi=
S@ J!=55&ffffi | $H!flffiffiffiD|RI 4 ff8fl.
8&ffT!
UMH! "5;
= j9$&ffffi+,  xH!9+,
ff98 fl
= jH!S
I!
 +,
Sdffi5:
=8&
>cufff ffiAwO""! -fff)Na
=8A-59M1)
$&ff
Sd&-5&
 $1flffi-!
A  Qffi"5fiA -M&ff#!ff ffi<
;!=5!
$9
;!$$A- fl"!S
= ffi ffi"5&ffiD;^n
ff
 +,$1
ff #!
AN3OcjLffiAN,H!S2+, flff
.Buff ffiAT43&4ffi+,rA  un±v
ffu.
$A-!
flffi@b,† 
ªS•&L!
 A "5J <$H!ff  M1ffifl"!
8 I
flffi
=+,$A *& i3 "5"5
 X"!
fl#X ffdffx
0 8$$1
ff x+%8AN $A <$1ff
= !
A N-ffiDr\i: ffiffi+,"5
!c+2!
$$ /:gff
=+K! $1ffiflffiNtHflUb%$1fff
= H!A  i3J
M!
 :b% ff .
d> flffiffi) 9!
$$A -flffi!
= J!=55>ffffi ) $H!flffiIflffi
8A-59 -+,$A  g3#!
 u
! H50ffffi58fl:x
Sdfff"!
5ED
b: F
JFuf3l5&ffi  /= ‘5&ffiflffi  
= sfi+2!=5&v lv434+
I!
9
;8 ,
M&'(ffifl .B
ff ffi "5ƒÕBbbÖx5&ffi  /= F$1ffd
!
  dA 3D2±v
ffu
gff
=+¯,ÃU  dff Ni37
R{
ff

 JRa
ff H!
5
;$&ff
'(ffifl0† W"¬S•H!=5
5&ffi+,
= 4 ff#!"5,H!S!
jbbÆ+,
>5&
=A
=/32H!Iffi flffi
8ff#!/=ffiA
.
flffi!
AP +,$A ffi+,ffi #!
I!
T +,$1
ff #! >cL
ff!
fl# ffid> /J/

>50+%8AN.
 $&ff
flffiffi 
ff2$1fff L
ff+2! flffi
Dk>#!S"5G!
ANff H!S dffiAN3O/
A
=MH!A5!#!
4 ff8fl8ffffiO1$1
=A  flffi ffiffiOa!
5j-+,$A ffi+,ffi #!
= 5
2 
: fl"!A <ffiA A—™
A
fl"!AI +,$A ffi+,ffi #!S-
9!Sff, ffi"5&"5ED,±ƒ A 0Ra
ff H!
5
n
flffi8 ffi5
$&ff +2!ff AN37
F*&$A
  /j
=M>'4ffiflf%
ff ffi #!
= F
0-+,$&ff
SdJ+%8AN.
 $&ff
flffiffi 
ffn$1ff L
ff+2!
flffi=O@;v$ff
S'4ffifl08 ffi5ƒ 0!A-
fi

N|
g(I!ff@ffi /
 ffiff /x!=5&d=! #!
/=
Hff"5&8flffi /U+2!
 ffi H! flffi
fl
=4U!
H5Vffi H!MA  /r  
Sd=!S
= aD
€!
8ANTfl
= #!
 +, >I!
5,ffflffi
Sdff 32 T!%  /
NtHfl"! T   8U
ff@
$.
fff#! /G43&4ffi+,,H!S0ff8 ¶!
flff
 nA-!ff/
v >8+%M1ff,
9$&ff
flffiffi4.

ffffiDIRIxflffiffiA A 8A-!Sff:!$$&ff
!
fl#;!
5
=$&"50M32³U-d=†NW=W•{!
50³U8ff ffN.
flffi!
=† ª=¬S•)!=5nM1ffi s5ffi+,"50M3VM1
j/ff
=8$
)ffffi "!SffflfffU

!"d

< /
0!9$1ff 
ff+2!
flffi:fl
=4"D|\( 2xx5&ffiflffi-5"5r
<*>.
$A
ffT!+,
>5ffiA=Ifl"!A-A "5r×I¢=¢1Ÿ ¡—¥½
 w¡—¤
¨JœX½
¨1½"©¦f£#§Dcb: %A-!Sff/=I43&4.
+,ffiO1+J8A  $A-<b>ffi:
d=!Sff 3 /, -Qffi:I
8A-5;M19+J8AN $A *&"5PD
oU v!
$$A  fl"!
= 7H!%5&g5X 
ff"Ø8Nff,+2!
3;ffffi
8ffflffiffi
=8A-5
ff8 fi
G!
qb7 4#! flffiV fl"!A-ffi5G
;NJ ffi"5&ffiDFb:8&ff%!
$$&ff
!flf
5NePffffi5Ggff
=+Ô}x  flffi
q†NW"Y•U k!rL!
8A 2fl
= #!
 +, >JM1
=8 H5&.
!ff ffi@Ifff<M1f(Iffi sb&@!@Ifff9 +,+%8AN $A *&"5,ff#!fff
H! q $!
flffin+J8AN $A *&"5PDG±Fj!  8+,"5fiH!Sr0+J8A  $A-f*&.
 /r
=8A-5jM1+2! H!
/
"5jM3Vflffi

=$1ff#!S d%+, -+2!Aau=ff ffiA ffiO 

 +,$1
= "5VM3n! j*>ff !
APffi N(3D
2. INTRODUCTION AND GOALS
RII$&ff
'(ffifl  {!
9
=$1ffi &.B
=8ffflffffi ffi!fffl#<
$1ff#! /43&4ffi+
uff ffiA  fl
ff$1
ff#!S /V-  
Sd
! d9+,ffifl#H!
  +,ffiOH 
SdA $1
=A  flffi ffiffiO
!
50+,
>5&ff n$&ff
=/
ff#!+,+, /%flf 
=A
/= ffiffiD
\( VI!Sffx*!
+, - /<x   8ffiT
|5 -/
 /J!%flffi
+,$A 

=$1fff#! /<43&4ffi+?ufff ffiAwD)\BI I
= U
a¶ffffiflffi >cffffi "!Sffflf
$ff
S'4fl"†  Î OW"Z&O Y&O ="•!9!
55>ffffi  ffi9A-!ff/=f.i fl
=$1,
=$1fff#! /
43&4ffi+`ffffi ffi!fffl#v$ff
MA ffi+,ffiD<±¶ A r 
9ffidfff 3sA- r
Tfl
>5r
,T!9TffN ffi Xff
+¯ flff#!fl#aOaVI!
95&ffi  /= ffi5Xff
+·
/
ff
8 5«8$k
fi!=55&ffffi V fl"!
A-!M A  i3¶! H5ƒ5>3 !
+, fljflffi84
=+, Q"!S.

= fi
U43&4ffi+Ù ffd> flffiffiffiDjj 8$$1
ff Vma >8*vo:p|\! H5
o:]c\0† S•—OI!
A A
S@ /FNr
Xff8 G8 +,
>5&NtH"5fimE- >8&*G!
$$A  fl"!
= 
!
50A  Mff#!Sff-ffiD
RI<$ff flffi $A ffiU!:/=8-5&%
8ff5&ffi  /= X!ff2WSÖ@4 ff8fl8&ff /,
43&4ffi+Ú8  /fi+,
>5&8A-!ff"OU
=M>'4ffiflf .i
ff ffi "5¶flffi
>5=Ox=ÖV5ffi  /
 /
<43&4ffi+6
V fl"!A-<
0d=ff 3;A-!ff/
J H!Sff"5&.B+,ffi+,
ff 3j+%8AN $ff
.
flffiffi 
ffffiOaªÖTA-dff#!
/
 /29$1ff L
ff+2!
flffiJ!
5d
!
#!
/
ffi
cZ
.iMN
$ff
flffi 
ffffiO:Ö0!"d
-5 /fiflffi > ff#!A -Q"5¶flffi
>5s$H!S0!
5ƒ/=A
=M!
A
A
flfu>!
5r5!S#!:4 ff8flf8ffffiffiO
Î
Ö +,
Sd& /U43&4ffi+z8 flf-
H!A-Ni3%

!
$$A  fl"!
jA -M&ff#!ff ffi@H!STffffi -5 0!
$$A  fl"!
= ffi1!
55&ff 
 $H!flffiffiffiOP! H50ZÖT+,
d> /%43&4ffi+[L8 fl
= !
A N(30ff
=+„uff A

n fffdff$&ff
flffiffi  ffiffiD<±¶ A JrM1ffiA  ffidJ sffi r5ffi  /= X$ff &.
flffi $A ffiffiOH
=8ff$&ff-+2!Sff 3Vffi+,$!
  @-
= n$1ff L
ff+2!
fl=DTRIffL
ff=O
!
J ffi"5&"5EO|nH!"dV+2!=5&2flffi
=+,$&ff
=+,  ffi%ff#!SffJH!
Gfl"!Sff ff 3>.
 /jffi 25ffi  /
fi$ A
=
$-<
;*> ffffi+,- v
ff#5fff%
n8A AN3
*&$A
ffxffiNff@ff#!
+,NtHflffi!
= ffiD
˜:
!A U
)x%$ff
S'4ffiflf: flA-85=–
ÛU‰>ŁSÜBÝHŁ
”7‹HŽ Þ
‰Pß0WSÖ9&flffi!
A r8$X
0ff8 7IA-A
= 7A-!ff/=2+%8AN $ff
.
flffiffi 
ffV!
H5G 8$$1
ff ,A-!Sff/=.B fl"!A-s!$$A- fl"!S
= 2Érflffi ffi A 3D«
Ö
&flffi!
A @5
"@ J
ff8 %ffiA A
J +2!
A A&+J8A  $&ff
flffiffi 
ffffiDª=Ö|&8$$1
ff 
 +2!
A AN.B fl"!
A V!
$$A  fl"!
r!9É,flffi ffi AN3v
FA-!ff/
V+%8AN $ff
flffi4.

ffU!
@
j +2!
A AE+J8AN $ff
flffi 
ffffiD
à%á
“ffiŒÝP”vâ‹ã)LäLgŒf’|ßnW"Ö:oUA A
"K!
$$A -flffi!
= x
j5fff+, VÕwM>3
fl#

=  /Jff
+„*&-4 /Jflffi
+,$1
=  >
ff@M3,TffN- /r f
= #Ö

"z%
$1ff#! /043&4ffi+6+2!
H!/=ffiffiNffUffffi
=8&ffflffiffiffiD%=ÖUoU8.

= 
=+, fl"!A-AN3«H!"dj;43&4ffi+Ò!
5!$V
fiflf!
/
 /FI
ffu>A-
=!=5
fl#H!ff#!flff 4 flffiffiD
å
ˆ ˆ)äLLÞ
‹ã)L䍌f’¶W"Ö@~)ePffifl dA 30 8$$1
ff U!%@-59d
!ff i30
|43&4.
ffi+,U!
5j$ff
=MA ffi+`5&
=+2!- ffiDU=ÖU^j!
u<N:"!43j
2+,
>5N30

=$1fff#! /0434+h
V 8$$1
ff  z$&ff
flffiffi 
ff%! H5;43&4ffi+·!Sff .
fl#Nffifl8&ffffiffiDhªÖj>8$$1
ff 0434+,0ff#!
/= /kff
+æffi+%M1"55&"5
$ff
flffi 
ff
J /
.Bffi H5Vffi ff$ff   ffd=ffffiD
çhLè{‰7‹&é&‹Hä‹ã)äLŒ#’ßrW"Ö]cJ!"d
!
 A-!
MA <
2!2A-!Sff/=<
=$1ffi &.i
8ffflffi
!
5rffffi "!fffl#2flffi
=+,+%8  i3D)
Ö^j!uUN"!
43r
<!
55, $1ffiflffi-!
A  Qffi"5
flffi
+,$1
=  >T
ffU*&$1ff +,ffi - /J@Nj$1
=A  flffi ffi! H5n +,$A-+,ffi .
#!
v4 ff#!/= ffiffiD,ª=Öb:$1ffi s8$sL
ff9*&$1ff +,ffi #!
= s$H!Sff 

:434+?H!S!ff: ff#!
5N
= H!A A 3n!
flflffiffi   MA 9
= A 32
%*&$1ff ffiD
³x!"d> /v5ffi flff M1"5q
=8ff2
Sdfff#!fffl# /F/
!A-0!
5q$&ff- flffi $A ffiffiO@
,ffffi4%
,$!
$1ff%I2$ff ffi r!; 8+,+2!Sff 3X

=8&ffr5& ePfff .
ffi Vffffi "!fffl#5Nffffiflf-
VIX$8ff 8"5« ¶Dê±F;M1ffi/
- 
&fl
= qª;@Nq!75&  flffi8  
= k
: J fl"!
A-!
M A-Ni3DkRIffi EO
&fl
= fiO{IV5ffi flfff-M12+,ffi+,
ff 3X!
A A
fl"!
aO@ flfv-<u3s

Sign up today - FREE

Mendeley saves you time finding and organizing research. Learn more

  • All your research in one place
  • Add and import papers easily
  • Access it anywhere, anytime

Start using Mendeley in seconds!

Already have an account? Sign in

Readership Statistics

28 Readers on Mendeley
by Discipline
 
 
by Academic Status
 
54% Ph.D. Student
 
14% Student (Master)
 
11% Student (Bachelor)
by Country
 
46% United States
 
18% China
 
4% Italy