Methodological issues in validating decision-support systems for insulin dosage adjustment

Abstract

Safety and reliability of advice from new computer systems should be confirmed before embarking on prospective hospital trials. This process of preliminary testing is termed 'validation'. Though it forms a fundamental stage in system development, few standards exist for choosing and implementing tests. In the present paper, a validation methodology is developed in the domain of diabetes and intended for general use in chronic health management. It is based on a peer review protocol and incorporates empirical measures indicating: applicability of results to the real environment; variation among doctors; comparisons between doctors' and computer advice; and relative merits of different computer algorithms. © 1994.