Adhesion of mutans streptococci to self-ligating ceramic brackets: In vivo quantitative analysis with real-time polymerase chain reaction

Abstract

Summary Objective: To analyze in vivo mutans streptococci (MS) adhesion to self-ligating ceramic brackets [Clarity-SL (CSL) and Clippy-C (CC)] and the relationships between bacterial adhesion and oral hygiene indices. Materials and methods: Four central incisor brackets from the maxilla and mandible were collected from 40 patients (20 patients per each bracket type) at debonding immediately after plaque and gingival indices were measured. Adhesions of Streptococcus mutans, S. sobrinus, and total bacteria were quantitatively determined using real-time polymerase chain reaction after genomic DNA was extracted. Factorial analysis of variance was used to analyze bacterial adhesion to the brackets with respect to the bracket type and jaw position. Correlation coefficients were calculated to determine the relationships of bacterial adhesion to oral hygiene indices. Results: Adhesion of total bacteria and S. mutans to CSL was higher than that to CC (P < 0.001). Adhesion of total bacteria to the mandibular brackets was higher than that to the maxillary ones (P < 0.001), while adhesion of S. mutans to the maxillary brackets were higher than that in the mandibular ones (P < 0.001). In particular, the proportion of S. mutans to total bacteria in CSL was higher than CC (P < 0.05) in the maxillary anterior teeth (P < 0.001). There were no significant differences in adhesion of S. sobrinus between the brackets and jaw positions. Interestingly, no significant relationships were found between bacterial adhesions and oral hygiene indices. Limitations: Complex bracket configurations may significantly influence bacterial adhesion to orthodontic brackets. Further in vivo study using bracket raw materials will help to define the relationships between bacteria adhesion and enamel demineralization. Conclusions: Because oral hygiene indices were not significantly correlated with adhesions of MS to self-ligating ceramic brackets, careful examinations around the brackets should be needed to prevent enamel demineralization, regardless of oral hygiene status.