Stochastic effects are important in intrahost HIV evolution even when viral loads are high

Abstract

Blood plasma viral loads and the time to progress to AIDS differ widely among untreated HIV-infected humans. Although people with certain HLA (HLA-I) alleles are more likely to control HIV infections without therapy, the majority of such untreated individuals exhibit high viral loads and progress to AIDS. Stochastic effects are considered unimportant for evolutionary dynamics in HIV-infected people when viral load is high orwhen selective forces strongly drive mutation. We describe a computational study of host-pathogen interaction demonstrating that stochastic effects can have a profound influence on disease dynamics, even in cases of high viral load and strong selective pressure. These stochastic effects are pronounced when the virus must traverse a fitness "barrier" in sequence space to escape the host's cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) response, as often occurs when a fitness defect imposed by a CTL-driven mutationmust be compensated for by other mutations. These "barrier-crossing"events are infrequent and stochastic, resulting in divergent disease outcomes in genetically identical individuals infected by the same viral strain. Our results reveal how genetic determinants of the CTL response control the probability with which an individual is able to control HIV infection indefinitely, and thus provide clues for vaccine design.