Is it possible to generate accurate 3D point clouds with UAS-LIDAR and UAS-RGB photogrammetry without GCPs? A case study on a beach and rocky cliff

Abstract

Context: Recently, Unoccupied Aerial Systems (UAS) with photographic or Light Detection and Ranging (LIDAR) sensors have incorporated on-board survey-grade Global Navigation Satellite Systems that allow the direct georeferencing of the resulting datasets without Ground Control Points either in Real-Time (RTK) or Post-Processing Kinematic (PPK) modes. These approaches can be useful in hard-to-reach or hazardous areas. However, the resulting 3D models have not been widely tested, as previous studies tend to evaluate only a few points and conclude that systematic errors can be found. Objectives: We test the absolute positional accuracy of point clouds produced using UAS with direct-georeferencing systems. Methods: We test the accuracy and characteristics of point clouds produced using a UAS-LIDAR (with PPK) and a UAS-RGB (Structure-from-Motion or SfM photogrammetry with RTK and PPK) in a challenging environment: a coastline with a composite beach and cliff. The resulting models of each processing were tested using as a benchmark a point cloud surveyed simultaneously by a Terrestrial Laser Scanner. Results: The UAS-LIDAR produced the most accurate point cloud, with homogeneous cover and no noise. The systematic bias previously observed in the UAS-RGB RTK approaches are minimized using oblique images. The accuracy observed across the different surveyed landforms varied significantly. Conclusions: The UAS-LIDAR and UAS-RGB with PPK produced unbiased point clouds, being the latter the most cost-effective method. For the other direct georeferencing systems/approaches, the acquisition of GCP or the co-registration of the resulting point cloud is still necessary.