Experimental study of an original radiographic view for diagnosis of cam-type anterior femoroacetabular impingement

Abstract

Purpose Primary paraclinical investigation to look for femoral morphological abnormality consistent with cam-type anterior femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) must include specific radiographic projections of the hip from the following: cross-table, frog-leg or Dunn (90° and 45° flexion). We use a frog-leg type view with fixed angles as described by Chiron, obtained with the patient in a supine position, with the hip in 45° flexion-abduction and 30° external rotation. The X-ray beam is anteroposterior and centred on the femoral head. We evaluated this view by comparing it with other views in common use. Methods In this experimental study, we created artificial radio-opaque morphological abnormalities secured onto normal femoral necks. The femurs were placed in relation to a fixed pelvis using orthogonal landmarks, in the positions of the various radiographic views. The digital radiographs were analysed by two observers. Nineteen femurs were included to reveal a difference of 5° between the alpha angle of Nötzli et al. [11] measured on the Dunn view and the frog-leg 45/45/30 view (Student's paired test). Results The highest mean values of the alpha angle of Nötzli were always obtained with the frog-leg 45/45/30 view (87.4°, 86.2°, 84.5°) and the lowest with the crosstable view. We found a mean difference of 8.95° with the 90° Dunn view (P=0.00007), 3.44° with the 45° Dunn view (P=0.004) and 13.47° with the cross-table view (P=0.002). Conclusions This experimental study confirmed the value of the frog-leg 45/45/30 view in assisting diagnosis of camtype FAI. © Springer-Verlag 2012.