Derivation of Lamproites and Kimberlites from a Common Evolving Source in the Convective Mantle: the Case for Southern African 'Transitional Kimberlites'

Abstract

'Transitional kimberlite' is a collective term previously used to classify rocks occurring in southern Africa that show bulk rock geochemical and Sr-Nd isotope features intermediate between (cratonic) lamproites and kimberlites. However, it is now well established that detailed petrographic and mineral chemical criteria represent a more robust approach towards the classification of kimberlites, lamproites and related rocks. Here, we re-assess the classification of southern African 'transitional kimberlites' by combining new petrographic observations and mineral compositional results for samples from six localities (Leicester, Frank Smith, Wimbledon, Melton Wold, Droogfontein, and Silvery Home) straddling the southwestern margin of the Kaapvaal Craton. These new data indicate that Leicester and Frank Smith are archetypal kimberlites, whereas Wimbledon, Melton Wold, Droogfontein, and Silvery Home represent bona fide olivine lamproites. We combine the mineral chemical results with new (Wimbledon) and existing bulk rock trace element and Nd-Hf isotope compositions, and emplacement ages, to assess whether the previously documented trends in Nd-Hf isotope vs time for these 'transitional kimberlites' constrain their petrological evolution. Modal groundmass mineralogy, bulk rock K/La and chromite compositions, the latter being a proxy for primitive melt composition, are linearly correlated with emplacement age and initial Nd-Hf isotope compositions. These observations suggest derivation of both older lamproites (181-115 Ma) and younger kimberlites (114-93 Ma), from a common evolving source. The temporal evolution of Nd-Hf isotope compositions in these rocks converge to values typical of archetypal Cretaceous kimberlites elsewhere in the Kaapvaal Craton, but are clearly different from the isotopic compositions of on-craton Kaapvaal lamproites (previously known as orangeites). This observation distinguishes the petrogenesis of the Wimbledon, Melton Wold, Droogfontein, and Silvery Home lamproites from those of 'typical' Kaapvaal lamproites. We hypothesize that progressive consumption of enriched and hence fertile K-bearing components in a common sub-lithospheric (i.e. convective mantle) source beneath the southwestern margin of the Kaapvaal Craton might represent a plausible scenario to explain the temporal evolution of petrographic and geochemical traits of the examined lamproites and kimberlites. A source in the lithospheric mantle is considered at odds with the contrasting location of the current localities as they occur both off- and on-craton. Migration of the African plate between 180 and 90 Ma over a relatively stationary convective mantle (plume?) source is not compatible with the spatial-temporal distribution of 'transitional kimberlites'. Instead, we invoke viscous coupling between an upper asthenospheric source and the lithosphere to reconcile a single evolving source with the geographic and age distribution of these rocks. This work supports the hypothesis that olivine lamproites occurring in intra-continental settings share similar genetic features with kimberlites.