Predictors and reasons for epilepsy patients to decline surgery: a prospective study

Abstract

Background: In patients with drug-resistant focal epilepsy, resective surgery is the most successful treatment option to achieve seizure freedom. However, a surprisingly high rate of patients declines their physicians’ recommendation to undergo removal of the seizure focus or—if necessary—further video-EEG monitoring (VEM). Methods: In this prospective study, consecutive patients in presurgical assessment with at least one scalp VEM between 2016 and 2018 were included. We assessed both epilepsy-related and psychosocial variables as well as decision-making of physicians and patients, including reasons for decline in the latter. Results: Out of 116 patients with a total of 165 VEM, 20 patients were eventually found to be ineligible for resection, 51 declined, and 45 agreed on recommendations for resection or further VEM diagnostics. Patients most frequently declined due to general fear of brain surgery (n = 30, 59%) and currently lower seizure frequency (n = 11, 22%). An independent predictor of patients’ decline was less epilepsy-related fear (OR 0.43; p = 0.02) assessed in a standardised questionnaire. Conclusion: Half of the patients potentially eligible for resective surgery decline the operation or further VEM procedures. Patients who decline are more fearful of brain surgery than of ongoing disabling seizures. More insight is needed to improve counselling of patients.