Re-situations of scientific knowledge: a case study of a skirmish over clusters vs clines in human population genomics

2Citations
Citations of this article
6Readers
Mendeley users who have this article in their library.

This article is free to access.

Abstract

We track and analyze the re-situation of scientific knowledge in the field of human population genomics ancestry studies. We understand re-situation as a process of accommodating the direct or indirect transfer of objects of knowledge from one site/situation to (one or many) other sites/situations. Our take on the concept borrows from Mary S. Morgan’s work on facts traveling while expanding it to include other objects of knowledge such as models, data, software, findings, and visualizations. We structure a specific case study by tracking the re-situation of these objects between three research projects studying human population diversity reported in three articles in Science, Genome Research and PLoS Genetics between 2002 and 2005. We characterize these three engagements as a unit of analysis, a “skirmish,” in order to compare: (a) the divergence of interests in how life-scientists answer similar research questions and (b) to track the challenging transformation of workflows in research laboratories as these scientific objects are re-situated individually or in bundles. Our analysis of the case study shows that an accurate understanding of re-situation requires tracking the whole bundle of objects in a project because they interact in particular key ways. The absence or dismissal of these interactions opens the door to unforeseen trade-offs, misunderstandings and misrepresentations about research design(s) and workflow(s) and what these say about the questions asked and the findings produced.

References Powered by Scopus

Inference of population structure using multilocus genotype data

28200Citations
N/AReaders
Get full text

DISTRUCT: A program for the graphical display of population structure

4249Citations
N/AReaders
Get full text

Genetic structure of human populations

2197Citations
N/AReaders
Get full text

Cited by Powered by Scopus

Learning by Imitation: An Alternative of Improvements in Scientific Knowledge

0Citations
N/AReaders
Get full text

On lowering guardrails

0Citations
N/AReaders
Get full text

Register to see more suggestions

Mendeley helps you to discover research relevant for your work.

Already have an account?

Cite

CITATION STYLE

APA

Griesemer, J., & Barragán, C. A. (2022). Re-situations of scientific knowledge: a case study of a skirmish over clusters vs clines in human population genomics. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences, 44(2). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40656-022-00497-9

Readers' Seniority

Tooltip

PhD / Post grad / Masters / Doc 2

67%

Professor / Associate Prof. 1

33%

Readers' Discipline

Tooltip

Philosophy 1

33%

Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Bi... 1

33%

Social Sciences 1

33%

Save time finding and organizing research with Mendeley

Sign up for free