Mode of Formation of “Ablation Hollows” Controlled by Dirt Content of Snow

Abstract

A contradiction has existed in the literature as to the conditions favoring formation of “ablation hollows” (“suncups”) on a melting snow surface. Some experiments find that these features grow under direct sunlight and decay in overcast, windy weather; whereas others find just the opposite result, that they grow best under cloudy, windy conditions and decay if exposed to direct sunlight. We find that the hidden variable in past experiments, which acts as a switch to determine which mode of formation can operate, is the absence or abundance of dark insoluble impurities in the snow. Direct sunlight causes ablation hollows to grow in clean snow and to decay in dirty snow (for dirt content below a critical value), because the dirt migrates to the ridges between the hollows, lowering the albedo at the ridges. By contrast, when ablation is dominated by turbulent heat exchange, the presence of dirt favours development of ablation hollows because the dirt migrates to the ridges and insulates them; albedo reduction has a negligible effect on ablation.This hypothesis is supported by an experiment which showed that the presence of a thin layer of volcanic ash on the snow inhibited formation of ablation hollows under direct sunlight.