Fish Alone Are Not Enough: Zoobenthos Improves Water Quality Assessment in Impacted Rivers

Abstract

This study examines fish communities in the heavily impacted Bistrița River, located in the Eastern Carpathians of Romania, where diffuse pollution from mining, domestic wastewater, agricultural and forestry activities emerged as the most severe pressures. Fish sampling was conducted at twenty sites across two Natura 2000 protected areas. Results showed that species richness and diversity were higher downstream (Z1–Z5), indicating improved ecological conditions compared to the upstream section (B1–B15). The fish-based Index of Biological Integrity (IBI) suggested overall good biological integrity, with excellent conditions (class I) recorded in 70% of sites. Redundancy analysis (RDA) further revealed that elevation and conductivity significantly shaped community structure, while the site-specific impact score had only marginal effects. To assess water quality and biotic integrity based on different communities, as required by the Water Framework Directive (WFD), five sites were selected for parallel sampling of diatoms and benthic invertebrates. Among these, zoobenthos proved the most sensitive to water quality degradation, with biotic indices indicating classes I to III. These findings demonstrate that assessments based solely on fish may underestimate ecological impacts, underscoring the need for complementary approaches that account for multiple biotic communities when monitoring riverine ecosystem health.