Internalizing communication

Abstract

Carruthers presents evidence concerning the cross-modular integration of information in human subjects which appears to support the "cognitive conception of language." According to this conception, language is not just a means of communication, but also a representational medium of thought. However, Carruthers overlooks the possibility that language, in both its communicative and cognitive roles, is a nonrepresentational system of conventional signals - that words are not a medium we think in, but a tool we think with. The evidence he cites is equivocal when it comes to choosing between the cognitive conception and this radical communicative conception of language.