Calidad de vida en pacientes con epilepsia y crisis no epilépticas psicógenas: una revisión sistemática

Abstract

Psychogenic non epileptic seizures (PNES) are disruptive changes in behaviour, thought, or emotion that resemble an epileptic seizure, but without paroxysmal neuronal discharge detectable by electroencephalography (EEG), and are not caused by another medical condition. On the other hand, epileptic seizures (ES) are defined as clinical events that reflect the presence of hypersynchronous discharges of neurons located in the cerebral cortex, which have the particularity of starting and ending abruptly. The diagnosis of epilepsy is made when an epileptic seizure was experienced and there is a risk of having another. The objective of this paper is to present the results of a systematic review of articles that have studied quality of life in people with PNES and ES. This review has been performed following the PRISMA guide (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses). Prior to the beginning of the search, a protocol was carried out and it is published for consultation in the International prospective register of systematic reviews (PROSPERO). The review includes randomized and non-randomized, quantitative or mixed, cross-sectional or longitudinal studies, published in English or Spanish until 2020. In addition, participants had to be over 16 years old. PNES diagnosis must have been confirmed by video-electroencephalography (VEEG) or a similar procedure-which is considered the gold standard for the diagnosis of PNES. In regards to research, PubMed, SciELO, Cochrane Library, Lilacs, Dialnet and Science Direct databases were reviewed. In addition, authors from epilepsy centers in Argentina were contacted in order to obtain local data and references of included studies were reviewed. The quality of the articles was evaluated using the guidelines of a tool created in a previous review by Brown and Reuber for PNES studies. It has been chosen to present the data in a narrative synthesis. As a result of the search, 678 references were obtained and after eliminating duplicates, 614 results were left. After filtering the results according to the selection criteria, 11 articles and a doctoral thesis were included. Their publication years date from 1998 to 2020. Most of them (10) were developed in the United States, one in Turkey and one in Argentina. English language was prevalent, being the doctoral thesis the only one written in spanish. Regarding the quality of the studies, most of them (9) were rated as medium quality; two of them as low quality and one as high quality. In regard to the scales employed to measure quality of life, the most widely used was Quality Of Life in Epilepsy (QOLIE), and QOLIE-31 was the most frequently used version of the instrument. It was found that people with PNES had a lower quality of life, mostly associated with the presence of psychopathology. Depression constitutes the most recurrent factor, followed by anxiety and personality traits. These results are consistent with previous research and gain importance when analysing the high rates of psychiatric comorbidity found in both groups of patients. To a lesser extent, other factors have shown a relationship with quality of life: taking anti-epileptic drugs, seizure-related factors (frequency, severity, duration of the disease), family functioning, demographic factors (sex), trauma and somatization. This study has potential limitations, including methodological problems of the articles included (non-randomized studies, dissimilar sample sizes between groups), quality of life scales dissimilarity among studies, and not having performed a meta-analysis, which would have provided more detailed information. Nevertheless, in conclusion, it could be stated that, in general, people with PNES have a lower quality of life than people with epileptic seizures.