Normal DXA bone mineral density but frail cortical bone in Turner's syndrome

Abstract

Context: Patients with Turner's syndrome have normal bone mineral density by dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA), but a predisposition for fractures. Quantitative ultrasonography (QUS) measures cortical bone strength. Objective: To compare QUS with DXA in patients with Turner's syndrome. Patients and methods: Twenty-seven Turner's syndrome patients, aged 21.1 ± 6.3 years (mean ± SD), were evaluated by DXA, measuring two-dimensional bone mineral density (BMD), and QUS, measuring speed of sound (SOS) of the radius and tibia. The results were compared to sex- and age-matched (Ctr A, n = 53) and height-matched (Ctr B, n = 34) control groups. Results: Fracture incidence per 1000 women years was 4.76 in Ctr A, 5 in Ctr B and 7.69 in Turner's patients. In Turner's syndrome patients, QUS results were significantly lower than in controls, whereas DXA Z-scores were not different from reference values. Correlation between tibia and radius SOS and height and age in controls (P < 0.0001) was not evident in Turner's syndrome. Oestrogen or growth hormone therapy had no effect on either QUS or DXA parameters. Conclusions: Bone fragility in Turner's syndrome is reflected by low SOS but not by DXA BMD. Low QUS, which assesses the cortical bone only, supports a defect in cortical bone in Turner's syndrome. Lack of SOS correlation with age, height and hormonal therapy in Turner's syndrome suggests a primary bone defect, rather than enhanced resorption of endocrine origin. © 2007 The Authors.