High tunnel and open field production of floricane- and primocane-fruiting raspberry cultivars

Abstract

Identical trials were conducted in a multibay high tunnel and an adjacent open field in southwestern Michigan to compare primocane-fruiting cultivars (Autumn Britten, Caroline, Chinook, Heritage) and floricane-fruiting cultivars (Canby, Encore, Heritage, Nova) of red raspberry (Rubus idaeus). Floricanefruiting plots of 'Heritage' were pruned to produce fruit on floricanes and primocanes (double cropping). The most productive cultivars in both environments were 'Nova' and 'Canby' (floricane) and 'Caroline' and 'Heritage' (primocane). These cultivars produced annual yields of 5.5 kg.m-1 row in the tunnel and 2.5 kg.m-1 row in the field. The order of primocane harvest (earliest to latest) was the same in the tunnel and field: 'Autumn Britten', 'Caroline', 'Chinook', and 'Heritage'. Cultivars with the greatest average berry weight in the tunnel and field were Encore and Nova (floricane) and Autumn Britten and Caroline (primocane). 'Chinook' and 'Autumn Britten' tended to have the highest incidence of gray mold (Botrytis cinerea) of primocane-fruiting cultivars, but incidence was similar in floricane cultivars. Overall mold incidence was 1% in the tunnel and 13% in the field. Leaf spot (Sphaerulina rubi), cane anthracnose (Elsinoe veneta), spur blight (Didymella applanata), and botrytis cane blight (B. cinerea) were common in the field but absent in tunnel. Phytonutritional analyses of primocane fruit indicated that genotype differences were not consistent across the two environments. Relative cultivar characteristics (harvest season, yield, berry quality) were similar in the field and tunnels, but the tunnel environment tended to increase plant vigor, yield, and fruit quality and suppress several diseases.