Effect of drainage layers on water retention of potting media in containers

Abstract

Excess water retention in the potting medium can be a significant problem for plants grown in containers due to the volume of saturated medium which forms above the drainage hole. Adding a layer of coarse material like gravel or sand at the bottom is a common practise among gardeners with the aim of improving drainage, but some researchers have argued that such layers will raise the saturated area and in fact increase water retention. Two different depths and four different materials of drainage layer were tested with three different potting media to determine the water retention in the container after saturating and draining freely. For loamless organic media, almost all types of drainage layer reduced overall water retention in the container compared to controls. For loam-based media, most drainage layers had no effect on the overall water retention. Two simple models were also used to estimate the water retention in the media alone, excluding the drainage layer itself. All drainage layers reduced water retention of loamless organic media, according to both models. There was disagreement between the two models applied to loam-based media, and further study is required to determine the most accurate. Both models showed that some drainage layers with smaller particle sizes reduced water retention in loam-based media, but disagreed on the effect of drainage layers with larger particle sizes. Overall, any drainage layer was likely to reduce water retention of any medium, and almost never increased it. Thicker drainage layers were more effective than thinner layers, with the most effective substrate depending on the potting media used. A 60 mm layer of coarse sand was the most universally-effective drainage layer with all potting media tested.