Duplicate entries in the Protein Data Bank: how to detect and handle them

Abstract

A global analysis of protein crystal structures in the Protein Data Bank (PDB) using a newly developed computational approach reveals many pairs with (nearly) identical main-chain coordinates. Such cases are identified and analyzed, showing that duplication is possible since the PDB does not currently have tools or mechanisms that would detect potentially duplicate submissions. Some duplicated entries represent modeling efforts of ligand binding that masquerade as experimentally determined structures. We propose that duplicate entries should either be obsoleted by the PDB or, as a minimum, marked with a clear 'CAVEAT' record that would alert potential users to the presence of such problems. We also suggest that using a tool for verifying the uniqueness of the deposited structure, such as that presented in this work, should become part of the routine validation procedure for new depositions.