An exploration of the barriers to the confident diagnosis of irritable bowel syndrome: A survey among general practitioners, gastroenterologists and experts in five European countries

Abstract

Background: The diagnostic processes for chronic abdominal conditions are challenging. Despite their tendency for diagnostic tests in patients with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) symptoms, clinicians are encouraged to make a positive diagnosis based on symptom criteria without alarm signs. We explored how European physicians diagnose and manage patients suffering from IBS. Methods: We conducted a vignette-based survey to evaluate the diagnostic approaches in four standardized patients with IBS with constipation (IBS-C), IBS with diarrhea (IBS-D), inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) and chronic constipation (CC). General practitioners (GP, n=104), gastroenterologists (GE, n=100) and IBS experts (n=25) from five European countries participated. Results: Experts showed the highest rates of correct diagnoses (88%–92%) for all cases except CC (only 60%) and were more prone to a positive diagnosis (64%/68% in IBS-C/CC), whereas GEs and GPs tended toward a diagnosis by exclusion (63%/63% and 62%/60% in IBS-C/CC). In the CC vignette, conducting tests was more frequent than prescribing treatment among 44% experts, 63% GEs and 36% GPs. The diagnosis of IBD presented little difficulty for any of the participants. Conclusions: This study highlights the difficulties in confidently diagnosing chronic functional bowel conditions, especially for non-experts, whereas IBD caused little difficulty. Differentiating between IBS-C and CC seemed particularly challenging, even for experts.