The Ambitions of Wizards and the Warnings of Prophets: Religious Guidance on Climate Change?

Abstract

Secular wizardry and secular prophecy are two responses to climate change. Secular wizardry involves implementing technological solutions. Prophecy involves demanding conversion to a different way of life, warning against the hubris of “playing God.” Prophets do not predict the future but speak truth to power. Wizards are not playing God but striving for morally responsible action. What to do about climate change? Can religions provide guidance? Traditions are reformed when used to address current concerns, as scholars may see in the greening of religions. Replacing religions with a science-based cosmic epic has its own weaknesses, as do experiential green religions. Philosophical justification for addressing climate change is limited too, unless there is another underlying commitment, whether articulated in religious, humanist, or political terms. Humanity needs smart technology, but also appropriate pluralistic politics. The alternative is not prophecy but lament for the conditions that our grandchildren and their offspring will face.