Comparative analysis of material criteria in neighborhood sustainability assessment tools and urban design guidelines: Cases of the UK, the US, Japan, and Korea

  • Say C
  • Abu Bakar A
  • Cheen K
 et al. 
  • 1


    Mendeley users who have this article in their library.
  • N/A


    Citations of this article.


Sustainable neighbourhood standards, such as BREEAM Communities, have been examined by various researchers. There is less research that directly contrasts some of the more fundamental assumptions in such standards with core concepts applied in the field of urban design. This paper summarises a literature review which examines narratives around sustainable development, urban design and neighbourhood masterplanning. Two areas are identified that affect the standard’s uptake and application: (i) the need for greater consistency in BREAAM Communities’ structure, including how ‘global’ sustainability issues are addressed in differing local contexts and stakeholder agendas, as well as the need for post-construction validation; (ii) how BREAAM Communities might better reflect the wider context, where numerous factors impact construction sector application of voluntary standards, (e.g. the rate developments enter the market, private and public sector demand for ‘sustainable’ neighbourhoods, perceptions of cost, administrative burden and relevance). It is these technical and contextual concerns that may ultimately determine how successful a standard can be in achieving its aims for sustainable urban development. Further empirical research is required to understand evaluative and decision-making practices in masterplanning and how BREEAM Communities may contribute to them.

Author-supplied keywords

  • Assessment
  • BREEAM communities
  • Building
  • Material
  • Neighborhood sustainability assessment tools
  • Sustainability
  • Sustainable
  • Sustainable urban development
  • Urban design guideline
  • assessment framework
  • building
  • certification
  • evaluation model
  • green building rating tools
  • index system
  • neighborhood sustainability assessment
  • s life cycle
  • sustainability indicators
  • sustainable development
  • urban development
  • urban traffic system

Get free article suggestions today

Mendeley saves you time finding and organizing research

Sign up here
Already have an account ?Sign in

Find this document


  • Candace Say

  • Abu Hassan Abu Bakar

  • Khor Soo Cheen

  • Fuh Yiing Chua

  • Mohd Yaacob Naziaty

  • Hussein Hazreena

Cite this document

Choose a citation style from the tabs below

Save time finding and organizing research with Mendeley

Sign up for free