Trace element systematics in granulite facies rutile: Implications for Zr geothermometry and provenance studies

Abstract

Metamorphic rutile from granulite facies metapelitic rocks of the Archean Pikwitonei Granulite Domain (PGD; Manitoba, Canada) provides constraints on the systematics of trace elements in rutile during high-temperature conditions and subsequent slow cooling. Compositional profiles and maps of the Zr concentrations in rutile grains (120-600μm) from three metapelitic gneisses were acquired by electron probe micro-analysis, using a spatial resolution of down to 2μm. Simultaneously, profiles were analysed for Nb, Cr and V, which have significantly different diffusion characteristics in rutile. The profiles of all elements show relatively homogeneous concentrations within most grains, but significant inter-grain differences even within a single thin section. Some rutile grains display a slight concentration decrease from a neighbouring garnet towards the matrix for all measured elements. The lack of diffusion profiles for all analysed elements shows that these are highly immobile in rutile and that distributions of these elements are primary and preserve prograde information. The Nb and Cr concentrations overlap with ranges that are ascribed to different provenances indicating that source discrimination based on these elements is not possible in all cases. High retentiveness for Zr implies that the Zr-in-rutile geothermometer is highly robust to diffusive re-equilibration, even during very slow cooling (<2°CMa -1) from granulite facies conditions. Most grains have high Zr contents (3000-4600ppm). Differences between high Zr contents suggest that during growth under vapour-absent conditions there may not be saturation of Zr in rutile, even if zircon is present. Therefore, several rutile grains need to be analysed in a sample to obtain a useful minimum peak temperature. The highest Zr concentrations correspond to ∼900°C. This is significantly higher than previous peak temperature estimates of 820°C based on two-feldspar thermometry. On a regional scale this implies that part of the PGD was affected by ultra-high temperature (UHT) metamorphism. It also implies that rutile is able to preserve primary compositions even to UHT conditions. This study shows that, if combined with textural information, Zr-in-rutile has the potential to be a very useful tool for estimating rutile crystallization temperatures and peak metamorphic conditions. For granulite facies rocks, Zr-in-rutile yields more reliable peak metamorphic temperatures than most other exchange geothermometers, which tend to partially re-equilibrate by diffusion during cooling. © 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd.