Increases in cigarette consumption and decreases in smoking intensity when nondaily smokers are provided with free cigarettes

Abstract

Introduction: Studies testing novel tobacco products often provide participants with free product and assess consumption. Some, but not all, studies find that providing free cigarettes increases smoking. We tested changes in smoking when free cigarettes were provided to nondaily, intermittent smokers, who constitute one-third of US adult smokers. Methods: Cigarette consumption was assessed byTime-Line Follow-Back in 235 intermittent smokers for two 2-week periods: when providing their own cigarettes and when provided own-brand cigarettes for free. Smoking topography and carbon monoxide boost were assessed for one cigarette at the end of each period. Results: Cigarette consumption increased significantly, by 66% (from 1.98 to 3.28 cigarettes per day), when cigarettes were available for free; both the number of days the subjects smoked and the number of cigarettes on those days increased.The increases were significantly greater among African Americans, those FagerströmTobacco Nicotine Dependence scores >0, those with incomes less than US $25,000 per year, those who engaged in greater conscious restraint of smoking, and for smokers of menthol cigarettes, or “longs.” Smoking intensity (smoke volume, by topography) and carbon monoxide boost decreased significantly when cigarettes were provided for free. Conclusions: Providing intermittent smokers with free cigarettes substantially increased their smoking while decreasing smoking intensity. The increases in smoking varied according to multiple individual and cigarette-type differences.These phenomena may complicate interpretation of studies that compare consumption of a free test product with cigarette consumption or constituent exposure when smokers are providing their own cigarettes. They also suggest that cigarette cost and variations in low-level dependence and in smoking restraint are factors in nondaily smoking. Implications:The study shows that providing nondaily smokers with free cigarettes increases cigarette consumption, but does differentially for different subgroups and cigarette types, while also decreasing smoking intensity.This suggests the value of using free-cigarette baseline data in studies where interventions provide free cigarettes.