Screening for borderline personality disorder with the mclean screening instrument: A review and critique of the literature

Abstract

Borderline personality disorder (BPD) is underdiagnosed in clinical practice. One approach towards improving diagnostic detection is the use of screening questionnaires. It is important for a screening test to have high sensitivity because the more time-intensive/expensive follow-up diagnostic inquiry will presumably only occur in patients who are positive on the initial screen. The most commonly studied self-report scale specific for BPD is the McLean Screening Instrument for Borderline Personality Disorder (MSI-BPD). We summarize the performance of the scale across studies, examine the performance of the scale using different cutoff scores, and highlight the approach used by investigators in recommending a cutoff score. Most studies of the scale have taken a case-finding approach in deriving the cutoff score on the scale instead of a screening approach. For the purposes of screening, it may be more appropriate for the cutoff score on the MSI-BPD to be less than the currently recommended cutoff of 7.