Correlations and analytical approaches to co-evolving voter models

Abstract

The difficulty in formulating analytical treatments in co-evolving networks is studied in light of the Vazquez-Eguíluz-San Miguel voter model (VM) and a modified VM (MVM) that introduces a random mutation of the opinion as a noise in the VM. The density of active links, which are links that connect the nodes of opposite opinions, is shown to be highly sensitive to both the degree k of a node and the active links n among the neighbors of a node. We test the validity in the formalism of analytical approaches and show explicitly that the assumptions behind the commonly used homogeneous pair approximation scheme in formulating a mean-field theory are the source of the theory's failure due to the strong correlations between k, n and n2. An improved approach that incorporates spatial correlation to the nearest-neighbors explicitly and a random approximation for the next-nearest neighbors is formulated for the VM and the MVM, and it gives better agreement with the simulation results. We introduce an empirical approach that quantifies the correlations more accurately and gives results in good agreement with the simulation results. The work clarifies why simply mean-field theory fails and sheds light on how to analyze the correlations in the dynamic equations that are often generated in co-evolving processes. © IOP Publishing and Deutsche Physikalische Gesellschaft.