A Comparison of Sampling Methods for Dealing with Imbalanced Wearable Sensor Data in Human Activity Recognition using Deep Learning

Abstract

Human Activity Recognition (HAR) holds significant implications across diverse domains, including healthcare, sports analytics, and human-computer interaction. Deep learning models demonstrate great potential in HAR, but performance is often hindered by imbalanced datasets. This study investigates the impact of class imbalance on deep learning models in HAR and conducts a comprehensive comparative analysis of various sampling techniques to mitigate this issue. The experimentation involves the PAMAP2 dataset, encompassing data collected from wearable sensors. The research includes four primary experiments. Initially, a performance baseline is established by training four deep-learning models on the imbalanced dataset. Subsequently, Synthetic Minority Over-sampling Technique (SMOTE), random under-sampling, and a hybrid sampling approach are employed to rebalance the dataset. In each experiment, Bayesian optimization is employed for hyperparameter tuning, optimizing model performance. The findings underscore the paramount importance of dataset balance, resulting in substantial improvements across critical performance metrics such as accuracy, F1 score, precision, and recall. Notably, the hybrid sampling technique, combining SMOTE and Random Undersampling, emerges as the most effective method, surpassing other approaches. This research contributes significantly to advancing the field of HAR, highlighting the necessity of addressing class imbalance in deep learning models. Furthermore, the results offer practical insights for the development of HAR systems, enhancing accuracy and reliability in real-world applications. Future works will explore alternative public datasets, more complex deep learning models, and diverse sampling techniques to further elevate the capabilities of HAR systems.