Bourdieu and the media: the promise and limits of field theory

Abstract

For the confirmatory factor model a series of inequalities is given with respect to the mean square error (MSE) of three main factor score predictors. The eigenvalues of these MSE matrices are a monotonic function of the eigenvalues of the matrix “ p = ¦ 1/2 › p [variant prime] ¨ p -1 › p ¦ 1/2 . This matrix increases with the number of observable variables p . A necessary and sufficient condition for mean square convergence of predictors is divergence of the smallest eigenvalue of “ p or, equivalently, divergence of signal-to-noise (Schneeweiss & Mathes, 1995). The same condition is necessary and sufficient for convergence to zero of the positive definite MSE differences of factor predictors, convergence to zero of the distance between factor predictors, and convergence to the unit value of the relative efficiencies of predictors. Various illustrations and examples of the convergence are given as well as explicit recommendations on the problem of choosing between the three main factor score predictors.