Pregnancy after subzonal insemination with spermatozoa lacking outer dynein arms

Abstract

The absence of outer dynein arms in the sperm flagellum induces an abnormal movement pattern associated with male infertility. These spermatozoa can decondense in zona-free hamster oocytes but result in a very low fertilization rate in in vitro fertilization. We hypothesized that subzonal insemination could help achieve fertilization and pregnancy. A randomized prospective trial (five couples, five cycles) comparing subzonal insemination (n = 31 oocytes) and routine IVF (n = 23 oocytes) was carried out. Oocytes were microinjected with 8.5 ± 3.6 spermatozoa. In a second series (nine cycles), all the oocytes were microinjected with 10.5 ± 4.3 spermatozoa. In the randomized series, the fertilization rate was 16.1% without polyploidy, whereas no fertilization was obtained after control IVF insemination. In the second series involving nine couples, six of whom were included in the first series, the fertilization rate increased to 57.8% with a 27.8% polyspermic rate. Eighty-eight per cent of the zygotes cleaved normally (29 out of 33). A total of 11 embryo transfers resulted in three pregnancies, one of which terminated one month later, a second being ongoing and the third delivering a healthy girl. A 21.4% pregnancy rate per cycle, with a 37.5% pregnancy rate per couple, justifies the use of subzonal insemination to treat this particular flagellar dyskinesia.