Assessment of needs and gaps in public health cadre in India - a situational analysis

Abstract

Background: A structured and organized public health set up with systematically trained personnel to manage and deliver public health services from grassroot levels to higher administrative levels with separate public health directorate is the need of the hour. The objective of this study was to conduct a situational analysis of public health cadre in select states in India to gain an in-depth understanding of the progress and explore the gaps and challenges in its implementation. Methods: Four states from the country were selected based on stages of implementation of the cadre. The WHO health systems framework was the basis of assessment. In-depth interviews of 78 stakeholders from public health system across various categories and levels were conducted. Results: Every state has a dedicated cadre for public health in the form of a separate hierarchical structure and Directorate. There are deficits in human resources skilled enough to manage and implement public health across all levels. Its penetration below districts level is limited. There are limited opportunities available for contractual staffs in terms of remuneration and job progression. The respondents strongly emphasized on having personnel with training in public health, especially at leadership positions. Funding was not reported to be a problem although some challenges in the timeliness of release of funds were reported. Under the existing Health Management Information System, duplication of data exists and there is underutilization of data for policy making. Conclusion: A dedicated public health cadre is under evolution in India. The main challenge is inadequate workforce skilled in public health management. States are committed to finding solutions to overcome these barriers.