Is response rate increment obtained by molecular targeted agents related to survival benefit in the phase III trials of advanced cancer?

Abstract

Background: It remains unclear whether response rate (RR) is related to survival benefit in phase III trials of advanced cancer treated with molecular targeted agents (MTA) in combination with standard therapies. Materials and methods: We carried out a systematic search of PubMed for randomized phase III trials of four solid tumors examining the efficacy of MTA when added to a standard therapy. We examined whether there were any associations between RR increment obtained by the addition of targeted agents (ΔRR) and survival benefit in phase III trials. Results: We identified 26 phase III trials of MTA with a total of 21 156 patients and 29 experimental arms of MTA. Studies which showed significant survival benefit had higher ΔRR compared with those which did not show significant benefit. In the receiver operating characteristic curve analysis, using a 7% gain as threshold value for ΔRR allowed assessment of survival benefit with high sensitivity and specificity. There were also significant relationships between ΔRR and hazard ratios for overall survival and progression-free survival in the linear regression analysis. Conclusion: RR increment obtained by the addition of MTA to a standard therapy may be useful to predict survival benefit in clinical phase III trials of advanced cancer. © The Author 2010. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the European Society for Medical Oncology. All rights reserved.