Miscarriage of justice? Postcolonial reflections on the 'Trial' of the maharajah of Baroda, 1875

Abstract

This article revisits the Baroda Incident 1875, providing a detailed examination of the Enquiry or trial' for the first time, and locating that examination in the wider socio-cultural context of the nineteenth century British Empire (especially the Raj) and the exporting of the British'/English legal culture to the Empire. The implications of the establishing of British principles of justice, including the value placed upon Indian-generated evidence and testimony by the courts, are explored, in order to establish the Baroda Incident as a significant miscarriage of justice. Using historical methodologies as well as postcolonial insights, it demonstrates that the concepts of justice on which the British prided themselves were intrinsincally racialised as well as gendered, with profound modern resonances. © 2007 Springer Science+Business Media B.V.