Early vaccine-mediated strain-specific cytokine imbalance induces mild immunopathology during influenza infection

Abstract

Influenza A viruses (IAVs) exist as distinct serological subtypes, with limited antibody cross reactivity compared with T-cell responses, leading to universal vaccines that elicit robust T-cell responses entering clinical trials to combat pandemic and zoonotic outbreaks. Previously we have extensively characterized the viral-vectored universal vaccine, Wyeth/IL-15/5flu, a group 1 hemagglutinin, H5N1-based vaccine using a vaccinia backbone with interleukin (IL)-15. The vaccine elicits robust T-cell responses to provide heterosubtypic protection from lethal infection; however, we have also observed short-term morbidity of vaccinated mice with a disparity between the effects of sublethal infection with group 1 and 2 IAV strains. At day 3 of H3N2 (group 2 IAV) infection, there was a heavily skewed T helper type 1 response in vaccinated infected mice with overproduction of cytokines and reduced chemokines, whereas H1N1 (group 1 IAV) infection had increased innate cellular responses. These findings suggest that increased and early immune activation by T-cell activating vaccines may induce mild immunopathology when there is a mismatch between non-neutralizing antibody and cross-reactive memory T-cell responses leading to exuberant cytokine production. Therefore, to avoid overstimulating proinflammatory immune responses upon infection, universal influenza vaccines that elicit strong T-cell immunity will need a robust cross-reactive antibody response.