STUDI KRITIS METODE KOMPARASI ‘ALI AL-MADINI DALAM MENILAI KUALITAS RIJA L AL-HADITH DAN IMPLIKASINYA TERHADAP PERIWAYATAN

Abstract

‘Ali bin ‘Abd Allāh bin Ja’far bin Nājih bin Bakr bin Sa’ad al-Sa’diy (778-849M), known as Ibn al-Madini, which has a lot of work in the field of hadith raises some Rijal al-hadith (narrators) assessment standards -hadith, among them; tolerate small errors made by the narrators, narrators who do not tolerate a major sin, weakness and memory errors degrade transmitters, etc.. ‘Ali al-Mādinī also use comparative methods in assessing the quality of Rijal al-Hadith. The results on other scholars assessment with the assessment of ‘Ali al-Mādinī there is a difference. In this paper also revealed the implications of the hadith narrated by different transmitters who has different result of the quality of Rijal al-Hadith between ‘Ali al-Mādinī with other scholars.