Field evaluation of sampling bias with plastic petri dishes for size-fractionated bioaerosol sampling

Abstract

Reusable glass dishes are recommended for use with the six-stage viable impactor for size-fractionated bioaerosol sampling. However, it is not convenient to use glass dishes because they are fragile and heavy, not to mention the time-consuming preparation process prior to bioaerosol sampling. On the other hand, disposable plastic dishes have been widely used in microbiology laboratories. However, plastic materials can retain electrostatic charges and may lead to sampling bias. The objective of this study was to evaluate the sampling bias with the use of plastic dishes when a multistage viable impactor is used for airborne fungi and bacteria sampling for field sampling. Two six-stage viable impactors were placed side-by-side 1 m apart in a 147-m3 room. One was used with plastic dishes and the other with glass dishes. Compared with the concentration data obtained with glass dishes, those collected with the plastic dishes demonstrated a significant difference for both fungi and bacteria. However, there was a strong correlation between the data obtained using glass and plastic dishes, which can be estimated by Cplastic = 0.88 Cglass for airborne fungi and Cplastic = 0.86 Cglass for airborne bacteria. When using plastic dishes fungi and bacteria counts were underestimated by 12% and 14%, respectively.Copyright 2015 American Association for Aerosol Research