Ultrasound-guided aspiration in addition to antibiotics for treatment of liver abscess in children: A randomized controlled trial

Abstract

Background and Aim: The criteria for aspiration for pediatric liver abscess are unclear. In this randomized controlled trial, we evaluated the efficacy of ultrasound-guided needle aspiration in addition to antibiotics in children with uncomplicated liver abscess. Methods: We enrolled 110 children aged 1–18 years (mean [SD] = 7.7 [3.7] years) with uncomplicated liver abscess. The primary outcome was clinical cure at 6 weeks (absence of fever and abdominal pain in the preceding 14 days with reduction in abscess size on ultrasonography). The secondary outcomes were clinical response at 4 weeks, fever resolution time, time to abdominal pain reduction and abdominal tenderness, duration of hospitalization, and treatment failure. Results: Clinical cure at 6 weeks was not significantly different (48/50 [96%] vs 39/46 [85%]; P = 0.082) between aspiration plus antibiotics group and antibiotics only group. The clinical response at 4 weeks was also comparable (49/50 [98%] vs 43/46 [93.5%]; P = 0.347). The mean (SD) of fever resolution time was significantly less in the aspiration plus antibiotics group (198 [90.8] h vs 248.2 [104.6] h; P = 0.014). Time to achieve reduction in abdominal pain (8.32 [3.1] vs 9.46 [3.1] days; P = 0.077) and abdominal tenderness (5.7 [2.4] vs 6.3 [2.3] days; P = 0.242), duration of hospitalization (16.6 [3.9] vs 18.2 [4.4] days; P = 0.07), and adverse event profile (9/50 [18%] vs 14/46 [30%]; P = 0.217) were comparable between the two groups. Conclusion: Majority of children with uncomplicated liver abscess achieved clinical cure at 6 weeks with intravenous antibiotics, irrespective of aspiration. However, needle aspiration may slightly reduce the duration of fever and abdominal pain/abdominal tenderness.