Direct Structure–Performance Comparison of All-Carbon Potassium and Sodium Ion Capacitors

Abstract

A hybrid ion capacitor (HIC) based on potassium ions (K+) is a new high-power intermediate energy device that may occupy a unique position on the Ragone chart space. Here, a direct performance comparison of a potassium ion capacitor (KIC) versus the better-known sodium ion capacitor is provided. Tests are performed with an asymmetric architecture based on bulk ion insertion, partially ordered, dense carbon anode (hard carbon, HC) opposing N- and O-rich ion adsorption, high surface area, cathode (activated carbon, AC). A classical symmetric “supercapacitor-like” configuration AC–AC is analyzed in parallel. For asymmetric K-based HC–AC devices, there are significant high-rate limitations associated with ion insertion into the anode, making it much inferior to Na-based HC–AC devices. A much larger charge–discharge hysteresis (overpotential), more than an order of magnitude higher impedance RSEI, and much worse cyclability are observed. However, K-based AC–AC devices obtained on-par energy, power, and cyclability with their Na counterpart. Therefore, while KICs are extremely scientifically interesting, more work is needed to tailor the structure of “Na-inherited” dense carbon anodes and electrolytes for satisfactory K ion insertion. Conversely, it should be possible to utilize many existing high surface area adsorption carbons for fast rate K application.