Legitimacy Intermediation in the Multilevel European Polity and Its Collapse in the Euro Crisis

Abstract

This essay re-examines the dual – republican and liberal – foundations of democratic legitimacy in the Western traditions of normative political theory. Considered in isola- tion, the European Union conforms to liberal standards but cannot satisfy republican criteria. Given these conflicting standards, debates on the alleged European democratic deficit have remained inconclusive. Moreover, they have failed to pay sufficient atten- tion to the multilevel character of the European polity and to the normative potential of legitimacy intermediation in its two-step compliance and legitimating relationships. I argue, however, that the capacity of democratic member states to legitimate the exer- cise of European governing functions is being destroyed in the present euro crisis, and I briefly discuss the implications of this new constellation.