Unit Energy Consumption as Benchmark to Select Energy Positive Retrofitting Strategies for Finnish Wastewater Treatment Plants (WWTPs): a Case Study of Mikkeli WWTP

Abstract

Retrofitting municipal wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) to energy positive is a major challenge faced by many water utilities. Selection of innovative technologies to achieve retrofitting goals is critical for capital improvement programs in WWTPs. This paper aims to provide a statistical analysis method of unit energy consumption in conventional Finnish WWTPs, presenting Mikkeli WWTP as a case study. The average energy consumption at Finnish WWTPs was quantified as a mean of 0.49 kWh/m3 with a standard deviation of 0.197. The statistical analysis showed that the total energy consumption in Finnish WWTPs are positively correlated with inflow rate and sludge production. However, the unit energy consumption decreases with increasing plant capacity. The energy benchmarking of Mikkeli WWTP confirmed the energy gap of 0.11 kWh/kg COD in electricity. The major energy saving potentials are attributed to secondary treatment, screening and grit removal, and influent pump stations. A plausible innovative retrofitting strategy comprising four emerging energy-neutral or positive technologies is proposed to maximally harness the chemical energy content in wastewater: enhanced primary sedimentation, staged anaerobic fludized membrane bioreactor (SAF-MBR) with completely autotrophic nitrogen removal over nitrite process (CANON), and co-digestion of sludge with organic food-waste. The net energy balance of emerging technologies showed a maximum energy saving potential of 1.26 kWh/kg COD, which could be sufficient to overcome the energy gap of Mikkeli WWTP, providing net positive energy surplus of 1.15 kWh/kg COD.