Phylogenetic analyses of the rbcL sequences from haptophytes and heterokont algae suggest their chloroplasts are unrelated

Abstract

Using the large subunit of RuBisCo (rbcL) sequences from cyanobacteria, proteobacteria, and diverse groups of algae and green plants, we evaluated the plastid relationship between haptophytes and heterokont algae. The rbcL sequences were determined from three taxa of heterokont algae (Bumilleriopsis filiformis, Pelagomonas calceolata, and Pseudopedinella elastica) and added to 25 published sequences to obtain a data set comprising 1,434 unambiguously aligned sites (~98% of the total rbcL gene). Higher levels of mutational saturation in third codon positions were observed by plotting the pairwise substitutions with and without corrections for multiple substitutions at the same site for first and second codon positions only and for third positions only. In accordance with this finding phylogeny reconstructions were completed by omitting third codon positions, thus using 956 bp in weighted- parsimony and maximum-likelihood analyses. The midpoint-rooted phylogenies showed two major clusters, one containing cyanobacteria, glaucocystophytes, a phototrophic euglenoid, chlorophytes, and embryophytes (the green lineage), the other containing proteobacteria, haptophytes, red algae, a cryptophyte, and heterokont algae (the non-green lineage). In the nongreen lineage, the haptophytes formed a sister group to the clade containing heterokont algae, red algae, and the cryptophyte Guillardia theta. This branching pattern was well supported in terms of bootstrap values in weighted-parsimony and maximum-likelihood analyses (100% and 92%, respectively). However, the phylogenetic relationship among red algae, heterokonts, and a cryptophyte taxon was not especially well resolved. A four-cluster analysis was performed to further explore the statistical significance of the relationship between proteobacteria, red algae (including and excluding Guillardia theta), haptophytas, and heterokont algae. This test strongly favored the hypothesis that the heterokonts and red algae are more closely related to each other than either is to proteobacteria or haptophytes. Hence, this molecular study based on a plastid-encoded gene provides additional evidence for a distant relationship between haptophytes and the heterokont algae. It suggests an evolutionary scenario in which the ancestor of the haptophyte lineage engulfed a phototrophic eukaryote and, more recently, the heterokont lineage became phototrophic by engulfing a red alga.