Cobalamin deficiency in general practice. Assessment of the diagnostic utility and cost-benefit analysis of methylmalonic acid determination in relation to current diagnostic strategies

Abstract

Diagnosing cobalamin deficiency is often difficult. We investigated the diagnostic strategies that 224 general practitioners used to assess cobalamin status and the criteria on which they based their decisions to supplement patients. From all serum cobalamin analyses carried out at a single laboratory during 1993, individuals with serum cobalamin concentrations <300 pmol/L were identified, and one patient per general practitioner was included. When serum methylmalonic acid (s-MMA) values >0.376 μmol/L were used as the 'reference standard' for cobalamin deficiency, the serum cobalamin assay had a diagnostic sensitivity of 0.40 and a specificity of 0.98. With the same reference standard, the diagnostic accuracy of the physicians' decision to supplement patients had the same specificity but a higher sensitivity (0.51). Cost-benefit analysis indicated that measurement of s-MMA can be recommended in patients with serum cobalamin >60-90 pmol/L and <200220 pmol/L, depending on its diagnostic accuracy.