Advanced Concepts in Rheology for the Evaluation of Hyaluronic Acid-Based Soft Tissue Fillers

Abstract

BACKGROUNDCrosslinked hyaluronic acid (HA)-based soft tissue fillers possess unique viscoelastic properties intended to match specific product indications. Manufacturing has an impact on HA chain integrity and on filler properties.OBJECTIVEThis study introduces 2 new rheological parameters to evaluate the macroscopic characteristics of fillers.METHODS AND MATERIALSA library of reference commercialized HA fillers was selected to cover the full spectrum of product indications. Gels were assessed in terms of size of released HA fragments as a readout of gel integrity, degree of modification, cohesivity, and rheological properties.RESULTSThe elastic modulus G′ often used to characterize fillers was shown not to follow macroscopic mechanical properties. To improve the mechanical characterization of fillers, Strength and Stretch scores were developed and tested. The Strength score defined the ability of a filler to sustain constant viscoelasticity over a wide range of constraints and represented the filler mechanical resilience. The Stretch score measured the propensity of a filler to deform in view to improve implant adaptation to facial animation for natural-looking results.CONCLUSIONStrength and Stretch scores sorted rheological parameters to macroscopic cohesivity assays more accurately than G′ and may thus help predict the gel behavior once implanted and submitted to facial dynamics.