Economic viability of under floor heating system: A case study in beirut climate

Abstract

This paper explores the economic feasibility of the underfloor heating system for the climatic conditions of Beirut. A case study of a typical residential room (150 m2) is selected to compare its heating energy requirement when using either the conventional convective heating system or the underfloor heating system at similar comfort and indoor air quality conditions. Two mathematical models are developed, a steady space thermal model to establish the energy consumption at the peak load and a transient simulation model to find the energy consumption during the winter heating season. In addition, the economic feasibility of the underfloor heating system is assesd when integrated with solar energy. Based on the steady space model, the calculated peak heating load is reduced by 20% when the test space is heated by the underfloor heating system and a thermal comfort level of PPD 18.3% is achieved for a floor temperature of 27.4 ºC. The simulation results of the transient space model indicates that the seasonal heating energy consumption is reduced by 18% and that the yearly energy savings is $104 for an on-off control strategy that maintains a PMV comfort level greater than-0.5. The pay back period of the underfloor heating system is 10 years for an initial incremental cost of $850. When integrated with 10 solar collector units, the yearly energy savings of the integrated system is increased to $350 and the pay back period is 14 years.