A comparative analysis of the foraging behaviour of the Chough Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax and the Alpine Chough Pyrrhocorax graculus coexisting in the Alps

Abstract

The foraging behaviour of the Chough Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax and the Alpine Chough Pyrrhocorax graculus was studied during summer and autumn in the western Italian Alps. We assessed feeding times, feeding rates and foraging techniques associated with different foraging habitats. The Alpine Chough is mainly a ground surface feeder, stays for a relatively short time at a feeding site (on average 2.1 min) and feeds quickly (on average 9.2 items/min). In contrast, the Chough is almost exclusively an undersurface feeder (digger and prober), stays at a feeding site twice as long as the Alpine Chough (5.4 min) and feeds four times as slowly (2.2 items/min). These differences suggest that the degree of actual ecological overlap is almost as low as possible for two species using the same Alpine pastures as foraging sites. Interspecific coexistence has occurred through a clear differentiation of foraging strategies and diets. The foraging efficiency (in terms of feeding rate) of the Alpine Chough was always higher than that of the Chough in all habitats where they occurred together. The Alpine Chough was more variable in the use of foraging techniques and more diversified in the use of foraging habitats than the Chough. In both species, juveniles fed less efficiently than adults: the foraging behaviour of the Chough is probably more difficult to learn than that of the Alpine Chough. Other data have also shown that the Alpine Chough is more opportunistic than the Chough in using seasonally available food. Considering the above, we suggest that the foraging behaviour of the Alpine Chough is more flexible and, perhaps, better adapted to the high mountain Alpine environment than that of the Chough. Two hypotheses concerning the ultimate reason why the Alpine Chough and the Chough have evolved divergent beak morphology are discussed.