A metaphor and a conceptual architecture for software development environments

Abstract

A conceptual architecture for software development environments (SDEs) is presented in terms of a new metaphor drawn from business enterprises. A metaphor is employed as the architecture is complex, requiring understanding from several perspectives. The metaphor provides a rich set of familiar concepts that strongly aid in understanding the environment architecture and software production. The metaphor is applicable to individual programming environments, software development environments supporting teams of developers, and to large-scale software production as a whole. The paper begins by considering three perspectives on SDEs, a function-based view, an objects-and-relations view, and a process-centered view. The process view, being the most encompassing, is held through the remainder of the paper. Three metaphors for organizing and explaining a process-centered environment are then examined, including the hierarchical contract model and the individual/family/city/state model. Next the corporation model is introduced and a detailed analogy is drawn between corporations and software development environments. Within the context of the corporation metaphor, three corporate organization schemes are reviewed and federal decentralization is argued to be most appropriate for an SDE. Relationships induced by such an organization are discussed and a mapping between the conceptual architecture and a possible implementation architecture is briefly discussed.