Prevalence of multimodal treatment in children and adolescents with ADHD in Germany: a nationwide study based on health insurance data

Abstract

Background: Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) ranks top among neurodevelopmental disorders in children and adolescents. Due to a large number of unfavorable outcomes including psychiatric comorbidities, school problems, and lower socioeconomic status, early and effective treatment of ADHD is essential. Multimodal treatment has become the gold standard in ADHD management, comprising pharmacotherapy and psychosocial interventions, e.g., psychotherapy. Yet, little is known about the prevalence of multimodal treatment in routine care. Methods: Based on German health claims data for the years 2009–2017, we identified children and adolescents aged 3–17 years diagnosed with ADHD and characterized them cross-sectionally (per calendar year) in terms of treatment status and psychiatric comorbidities. The detection of pharmacotherapy was based on dispensations of drugs to treat ADHD (e.g., methylphenidate); psychotherapeutic treatment was based on corresponding billing codes. Multimodal treatment was assumed if ADHD medication and psychotherapeutic treatment were coded within the same calendar year. Psychiatric comorbidities were based on outpatient and inpatient diagnoses. Prevalences of ADHD and proportions of different treatment options were calculated and standardized by age and sex. Results: In 2017, 91,118 children met the study criteria for ADHD (prevalence: 42.8/1000). Of these, 25.2% had no psychiatric comorbidity, 28.8% had one, 21.6% had two, and 24.5% had three or more. Regarding overall treatment status, 36.2% were treated only pharmacologically, 6.5% received multimodal treatment, and 6.8% were treated with psychotherapy only (neither treatment: 50.2%). With increasing numbers of psychiatric comorbidities, the proportions of patients with multimodal treatment increased from 2.2% (no psychiatric comorbidities) to 11.1% (three or more psychiatric comorbidities) while the proportions of untreated (from 56.8% to 42.7%) or only pharmacologically treated patients (38.4% to 35.0%) decreased. From 2009 to 2017, prevalences were stable and the proportion of patients with only pharmacotherapy decreased from 48% to 36.5%. Concurrently, the proportion of patients with neither pharmacotherapy nor psychotherapy increased from 40.5% to 50.2%. The fraction of patients with multimodal treatment ranged between 6.5% (2017) and 7.4% (2013). Conclusions: Multimodal treatment, although recommended as the standard of treatment, is rather the exception than the rule. It is, however, increasingly common in ADHD patients with psychiatric comorbidities.