Comparing methods of DC motor control for UUVs

Abstract

Adaptive and learning methods are proposed and compared to control DC motors actu-ating control surfaces of unmanned underwater vehicles. One type of adaption method referred to as model-following is based on algebraic design, and it is analyzed in conjunction with parameter estimation methods such as recursive least squares, extended least squares, and batch least squares. Another approach referred to as deterministic artificial intelligence uses the process dynamics de-fined by physics to control output to track a necessarily specified autonomous trajectory (sinusoidal versions implemented here). In addition, one instantiation of deterministic artificial intelligence uses 2-norm optimal feedback learning of parameters to modify the control signal, while another instantiation is presented with proportional plus derivative adaption. Model-following and deter-ministic artificial intelligence are simulated, and respective performance metrics for transient re-sponse and input tracking are evaluated and compared. Deterministic artificial intelligence outper-formed the model-following approach in minimal peak transient value by a percent range of ap-proximately 2–70%, but model-following achieved at least 29% less error in input tracking than deterministic artificial intelligence. This result is surprising and not in accordance with the recently published literature, and the explanation of the difference is theorized to be efficacy with discretized implementations.