Surgical treatment of otitis media with effusion: Ventilation tube versus topical application of mitomycin C

Abstract

The insertion of the ventilation tube (VT), which is the surgical treatment for otitis media with effusion (OME), is not free from complications and also limits social life because of the need of abandoning immersion baths. Mitomycin C is an antineoblastic that delays fibrosis and avoids stenosis in scars by its topical use. It permitted a longer ventilation of the middle ear in guinea pigs by delaying tympanostomies closure similarly to the ventilation tubes. Study Design: Prospective clinical trial. Aim: Observe and compare the efficacy of tympanostomy, effusion suction and insertion of the ventilation tube (VT group) versus results of tympanostomy, effusion suction and topic application of mitomycin C(MMC group), and also the duration of tympanotomy and incidence of complications in both groups. Results: MMC group showed a significant lower efficacy (52% versus 80%) than that of VT group (p=0.34). The occurrence of type B curve in the tympanometry and tube pharyngeal ostium free from adenoid tissue in the preoperative period represent poor prognosis factors. The topic application of mitomycin on the tympanostomy permitted a patency period of two to three weeks. On the VT group, otorrhea was observed in 13.3% of the patients. On the MMC group, despite its smaller efficacy, there were no complications or need of missing immersion baths. Conclusion: We concluded that VT showed better efficacy than mitomycin on this trial. However more study is needed specially focusing on higher mitomycin C concentrations, longer periods of application or its serial use, for the treatment of otitis media with effusion.