Assessment of Different Object Detectors for the Maturity Level Classification of Broccoli Crops using UAV Imagery

Abstract

Broccoli is an example of a high-value crop that requires delicate handling throughout the growing season and during its post-harvesting treatment. As broccoli heads can be easily damaged, they are still harvested by hand. Moreover, human scouting is required to initially identify the field segments where several broccoli plants have reached the desired maturity level, such that they can be harvested while they are in the optimal condition. The aim of this study was to automate this process using state-of-the-art Object Detection architectures trained on georeferenced orthomosaic-derived RGB images captured from low-altitude UAV flights, and to assess their capacity to effectively detect and classify broccoli heads based on their maturity level. The results revealed that the object detection approach for automated maturity classification achieved com-parable results to physical scouting overall, especially for the two best-performing architectures, namely Faster R-CNN and CenterNet. Their respective performances were consistently over 80% mAP@50 and 70% mAP@75 when using three levels of maturity, and even higher when simplifying the use case into a two-class problem, exceeding 91% and 83%, respectively. At the same time, geometrical transformations for data augmentations reported improvements, while colour distortions were counterproductive. The best-performing architecture and the trained model could be tested as a prototype in real-time UAV detections in order to assist in on-field broccoli maturity detection.