Being approximate: The ganser syndrome and beyond

Abstract

The Ganser syndrome, or "talking past the point," (originally identifying symptoms of inmates on remand when questioned by prison doctors), is explored as a form of insubordination against the stigmatizing effects of overdetermined diagnostic categories. The strategies of approximation that characterize the syndrome are likened to comedy routines/vaudeville styles and to their employment of punning, clownery, and ambiguity to challenge the more privileged cultural values of clarity, literalness, and precision. The seeming craftiness of Ganserians is related to the aesthetic tactics of the trickster figure and to the physical buffoonery of hysterics. Stylistically, this paper synthesizes the languages of critical theory, Grade Alien routines, personal narrative, jokes, and poetic reflections on the notion of being approximate. © 2003 Human Sciences Press, Inc.